Sale and Supply of Alcohol Act 2012

Sale and supply of alcohol generally - Appeals - Appeals to High Court

161: Appeals

You could also call this:

"What happens when you appeal an alcohol licensing decision to the High Court"

When you appeal a decision to the High Court, it is like a new hearing. You get to present your case again. The High Court looks at the evidence from the original hearing.

If there are questions about facts, the High Court looks at the evidence from the licensing authority. This can include written statements from witnesses or other materials the court thinks are useful. The court can also look at affidavits and exhibits from the original hearing.

The High Court can choose to hear some or all of the evidence again if it wants to. It must hear the evidence again if it thinks the original notes are incomplete. The court can also hear new evidence if it wants to.

If you appeal a decision, you must show up to the hearing. If you do not, your appeal will be dismissed. If you do not work on your appeal quickly enough, the other party can ask for it to be dismissed.

The High Court makes a final decision on your appeal. It can agree with the original decision, change it, or reverse it. The court's decision is final and everyone must follow it.

The High Court tells the licensing authority about its decision. The decision is treated as if the licensing authority made it. The court also returns any papers and exhibits it got from the licensing authority, as required by section 160(4).

This text is automatically generated. It might be out of date or be missing some parts. Find out more about how we do this.

This page was last updated on

View the original legislation for this page at https://legislation.govt.nz/act/public/1986/0120/latest/link.aspx?id=DLM3339642.


Previous

160: Procedure for commencing appeal, or

"How to appeal a decision about alcohol licensing to the High Court"


Next

162: Appeal against decision of licensing authority on question of law, or

"Challenging a licensing decision you think is wrong about the law"

Part 2Sale and supply of alcohol generally
Appeals: Appeals to High Court

161Appeals

  1. Every appeal is by way of rehearing.

  2. However, where any question of fact is involved in any appeal, the evidence taken before the licensing authority bearing on the question must, subject to any special order, be brought before the High Court as follows:

  3. as to any evidence given orally, by the production of a copy of the chairperson's note or of a written statement read by the witness while under oath, or of such other materials as the High Court may consider expedient:
    1. as to any evidence taken by affidavit and as to any exhibits, by the production of the affidavits and such of the exhibits as may have been forwarded to the court by the licensing authority, and by the production by the parties to the appeal of such exhibits as are in their custody.
      1. Despite subsection (2), the High Court may in its discretion rehear the whole or any part of the evidence, and must rehear the evidence of any witness if the court has reason to believe that any note of the evidence of that witness made by the chairperson of the licensing authority is or may be incomplete in any material particular.

      2. The court has full discretionary power to hear and receive further evidence on questions of fact, either by oral evidence or by affidavit.

      3. If the appellant does not appear at the time appointed for hearing the appeal, the appeal must be dismissed.

      4. If the appellant does not prosecute the appeal with due diligence, any other party to the appeal may apply to the High Court for the dismissal of the appeal.

      5. On hearing the appeal, the High Court may confirm, modify, or reverse the decision appealed against, and the decision of the court is final and binding on all parties.

      6. The Registrar of the High Court must transmit to the secretary of the licensing authority a memorandum of the decision of the court, and the decision, in relation to the proceedings appealed against, must be treated as if it had been given by the authority.

      7. The Registrar must also return to the secretary of the licensing authority any application, papers, and exhibits forwarded by the secretary pursuant to section 160(4).

      Compare