Social Security Act 2018

Enforcement: sanctions and offences - Sanctions for breach of obligations other than young person or young parent obligations - Hierarchy of sanctions

236D: Sanction for first failure: community work experience: replacement sanction if good and sufficient reason why cannot meet requirements

You could also call this:

"What happens if you can't do community work and have a good reason"

If you do not meet the requirements for community work experience, you might get a sanction. You can give a good reason why you cannot meet these requirements to the Ministry of Social Development. If they agree with your reason, they will give you a new sanction.

The new sanction will reduce your main benefit by half until you comply with the rules again. This sanction starts at different times depending on your situation. If your reason is related to some requirements, the sanction starts when you tell the Ministry of Social Development about your reason.

If you get this new sanction, you do not have to meet the old requirements anymore. The new sanction works like any other reduction of your benefit. You can comply with the rules again under section 261. But for some purposes, the new sanction is treated as if it started when the community work experience started.

This rule is also affected by other parts of the law, such as sections 243AAA, 243, 245 to 248, and 320 to 322.

This text is automatically generated. It might be out of date or be missing some parts. Find out more about how we do this.

This page was last updated on

View the original legislation for this page at https://legislation.govt.nz/act/public/1986/0120/latest/link.aspx?id=LMS1444301.


Previous

236C: Sanction for first failure: community work experience: failure without good and sufficient reason to meet requirements, or

"If you don't do your community work and don't have a good reason, your benefit payments might stop."


Next

237: Sanction for second failure: suspension of main benefit, or

"If you don't meet your obligations twice, your main benefit will be stopped until you meet them again."

Part 5Enforcement: sanctions and offences
Sanctions for breach of obligations other than young person or young parent obligations: Hierarchy of sanctions

236DSanction for first failure: community work experience: replacement sanction if good and sufficient reason why cannot meet requirements

  1. This section applies if, at any time after community work experience that is imposed on P has effect,—

  2. P has not met the requirements that apply to P under section 236B(4) (see also section 236C(2) and (3)); and
    1. P has satisfied MSD within the reasonable period specified in section 236C(4) that a good and sufficient reason existed as to why P could not meet those requirements.
      1. MSD must impose on P, without giving a section 252 notice, a replacement sanction under section 236(2) that is to reduce the rate of P’s main benefit by half until P recomplies, and that starts to take effect—

      2. at the time that P satisfied MSD that the good and sufficient reason existed, if the good and sufficient reason relates to requirements that apply to P under section 236B(4)(a) and that time is before or at the end of the prescribed search period (see regulations made under section 418(1)(ic)); and
        1. on the first day after the end of the prescribed search period (see regulations made under section 418(1)(ic)), if the good and sufficient reason relates to requirements that apply to P under section 236B(4)(a) and the time that P satisfied MSD that the good and sufficient reason existed is—
          1. after the end of the prescribed search period; and
            1. before or at the end of the prescribed minimum number of weeks (see regulations made under section 418(1)(id)); and
            2. at the time (within the reasonable period specified in section 236C(4)) that P satisfied MSD that the good and sufficient reason existed, if the good and sufficient reason relates to the requirements that apply to P under section 236B(4)(b).
              1. If a replacement sanction under section 236(2) is imposed under subsection (2),—

              2. P is no longer required to meet the requirements that apply to P under section 236B(4); and
                1. the replacement sanction under section 236(2) operates in the same way as any other reduction of the rate of P’s main benefit by half under section 236(2); and
                  1. P recomplies under section 261 (see section 261(3)(b)); but
                    1. for the purposes of the 13-week period in section 233A(1)(b), the replacement sanction must be treated as if it takes effect when community work experience that it replaces takes effect.
                      1. This section is subject to sections 243AAA, 243, 245 to 248, and 320 to 322.

                      Notes
                      • Section 236D: inserted, on , by section 17 of the Social Security Amendment Act 2025 (2025 No 25).